It took more than a year for the first dual core processors based off the Phenom
architecture to be released from AMD. Phenom hit in late 2007 and it wasn't
until late 2008 finally we saw dual core processors based somewhat off the
Phenom architecture with the Athlon X2 7750. Luckily that isn't the case with
Phenom II, launched early this year dual core processors will be in stores soon
and being announced now during Computex. We'll be looking at two of these: the
Phenom II branded X2 550 and the Athlon II X2 250. How do they stack up to AMD's
previous offerings? Let's find out.

The Athlon II X2 250 is a new 45nm native dual-core and not a harvested quad
core Phenom II which had a bad core or two. It features 1MB of L2 cache per core
but unlike Phenom II has no L3 cache. It also is the first processor from AMD
with hardware C1E low power state, all other C1E states for AMD processors are
controlled by the BIOS. It isn't a Black Edition so you'll have to bump up the
front-side bus for all overclocking. The memory controller runs at 2GHz with
128-bit wide memory controller. It is Socket AM3 so it supports DDR3 for future
proofing but as with all Socket AM3 processors it should run fine in AM2+
motherboards. The die size is 117.5mm with a transistor count of around 234
million. AMD rates it for 65W and a max temp of 74 degrees Celsius. The
processor will retail for $87 in 1,000 unit quantities.

The Phenom II X2 550 dual core is Phenom II quad core derived part with a bad
core or two or one that wasn't up to the task at running at the 3.1GHz the
processor runs at. It features 6MB of L3 cache, 512KB of L2 cache per core, 64K
of L1 cache, 128-bit wide memory controller, 6MB of shared L3 cache for all
cores. It is a Black Edition processor so the multiplier is unlocked allowing
for easier overclocking. The memory controller runs at 2GHz and it also is a
Socket AM3 processor built off a 45nm process but a larger 258mm die and a
transistor count of around 758 million. It takes up a little more power at
around 80W and is rated for a max temp of 70 degrees Celsius. This processor
will set you back $102 in thousand unit quantities.
AMD is also announcing two other processors today, energy efficient quad and
triple core processors. The Phenom II X4 905e runs at 2.5GHz and has a 65W TDP
and the Phenom II X3 705e runs at 2.5GHz and also features a 65W TDP.
Here are the specs from AMD for all four new processors they're announcing
today.
AMD Athlon™ II X2 Processor Specifications:
Model Number & Core Frequency: X2 250 = 3.0GHz
TRAY OPN# ADX250OCK23GQ
PIB OPN# ADX250OGQBOX
L1 Cache Sizes: 64K of L1 instruction and 64K of L1 data cache per core (256KB
total L1 per processor)
L2 Cache Sizes: 1MB of L2 data cache per core (2MB total L2 per processor)
Memory Controller Type: Integrated 128-bit wide memory controller *
Memory Controller Speed: 2.0GHz with Dual Dynamic Power Management
Types of Memory Supported: Support for unregistered DIMMs up to PC2-6400
(DDR2-800MHz) -AND- PC3-8500 (DDR3-1066MHz)
HyperTransport 3.0 Specification: One 16-bit/16-bit link @ up to 4.0GHz full
duplex (2.0GHz x2)
Total Processor-to-System Bandwidth: Up to 33.1GB/s bandwidth [Up to 17.1 GB/s
total bandwidth (DDR3-1066) + 16.0GB/s (HT3)]
Up to 28.8GB/s bandwidth [Up to 12.8 GB/s total bandwidth (DDR2-800) + 16.0GB/s
(HT3)]
Packaging: Socket AM3 938-pin organic micro pin grid array (micro-PGA)
Fab location: GLOBALFOUNDRIES Fab 1 Module 1
Process Technology: 45-nanometer DSL SOI (silicon-on-insulator) technology
Approximate Die Size: 117.5 mm2
Approximate Transistor count: ~ 234 million
Max Temp: 74o Celsius
Core Voltage: 0.85-1.425V
Max TDP: 65 Watts
*Note: configurable for dual 64-bit channels for simultaneous read/writes
AMD Phenom™ II X2 550 Black Edition Processor Specifications:
Model Number & Core Frequency: X2 550 Black Edition = 3.1GHz
TRAY OPN# HDZ550WFK2DGI
PIB OPN# HDZ550WGIBOX
L1 Cache Sizes: 64K of L1 instruction and 64K of L1 data cache per core (256KB
total L1 per processor)
L2 Cache Sizes: 512KB of L2 data cache per core (1MB total L2 per processor)
L3 Cache Size: 6MB (shared)
Memory Controller Type: Integrated 128-bit wide memory controller *
Black Edition processors support software selectable increases to memory
controller, HyperTransport, DDR3 and CPU core frequency.
Memory Controller Speed: 2.0GHz with Dual Dynamic Power Management
Types of Memory Supported: Support for unregistered DIMMs up to PC2-8500
(DDR2-1066MHz) -AND- PC3-10600 (DDR3-1333MHz)
HyperTransport 3.0 Specification: One 16-bit/16-bit link @ up to 4.0GHz full
duplex (2.0GHz x2)
Total Processor-to-System Bandwidth: Up to 37.3GB/s bandwidth [Up to 21.3 GB/s
total bandwidth (DDR3-1333) + 16.0GB/s (HT3)]
Up to 33.1GB/s bandwidth [Up to 17.1 GB/s total bandwidth (DDR2-1066) + 16.0GB/s
(HT3)]
Packaging: Socket AM3 938-pin organic micro pin grid array (micro-PGA)
Fab location: GLOBALFOUNDRIES Fab 1 Module 1
Process Technology: 45-nanometer DSL SOI (silicon-on-insulator) technology
Approximate Die Size: 258 mm2
Approximate Transistor count: ~ 758 million
Max Temp: 70o Celsius
Core Voltage: 0.850-1.425V
Max TDP: 80 Watts
*Note: configurable for dual 64-bit channels for simultaneous read/writes
MD Phenom™ II X4 905e Processor Specifications:
Model Number & Core Frequency: X4 905e = 2.5GHz
TRAY OPN# HD905EOCK4DGI
PIB OPN# HD905EOGIBOX
L1 Cache Sizes: 64K of L1 instruction and 64K of L1 data cache per core (512KB
total L1 per processor)
L2 Cache Sizes: 512KB of L2 data cache per core (2MB total L2 per processor)
L3 Cache Size: 6MB (shared)
Memory Controller Type: Integrated 128-bit wide memory controller *
Memory Controller Speed: 2.0GHz with Dual Dynamic Power Management
Types of Memory Supported: Support for unregistered DIMMs up to PC2-8500
(DDR2-1066MHz) -AND- PC3-10600 (DDR3-1333MHz)
HyperTransport 3.0 Specification: One 16-bit/16-bit link @ up to 4.0GHz full
duplex (2.0GHz x2)
Total Processor-to-System Bandwidth: Up to 37.3GB/s bandwidth [Up to 21.3 GB/s
total bandwidth (DDR3-1333) + 16.0GB/s (HT3)]
Up to 33.1GB/s bandwidth [Up to 17.1 GB/s total bandwidth (DDR2-1066) + 16.0GB/s
(HT3)]
Packaging: Socket AM3 938-pin organic micro pin grid array (micro-PGA)
Fab location: GLOBALFOUNDRIES Fab 1 Module 1
Process Technology: 45-nanometer DSL SOI (silicon-on-insulator) technology
Approximate Die Size: 258 mm2
Approximate Transistor count: ~ 758 million
Max Temp: 70o Celsius
Core Voltage: 0.825-1.25V
Max TDP: 65 Watts
*Note: configurable for dual 64-bit channels for simultaneous read/writes
AMD Phenom™ II X3 703e Processor Specifications:
Model Number & Core Frequency: X3 705e = 2.5GHz
TRAY OPN# HD705EOCK3DGI
PIB OPN# HD705EOGIBOX
L1 Cache Sizes: 64K of L1 instruction and 64K of L1 data cache per core (384KB
total L1 per processor)
L2 Cache Sizes: 512KB of L2 data cache per core (1.5MB total L2 per processor)
L3 Cache Size: 6MB (shared)
Memory Controller Type: Integrated 128-bit wide memory controller *
Memory Controller Speed: 2.0GHz with Dual Dynamic Power Management
Types of Memory Supported: Support for unregistered DIMMs up to PC2-8500
(DDR2-1066MHz) -AND- PC3-10600 (DDR3-1333MHz)
HyperTransport 3.0 Specification: One 16-bit/16-bit link @ up to 4.0GHz full
duplex (2.0GHz x2)
Total Processor-to-System Bandwidth: Up to 37.3GB/s bandwidth [Up to 21.3 GB/s
total bandwidth (DDR3-1333) + 16.0GB/s (HT3)]
Up to 33.1GB/s bandwidth [Up to 17.1 GB/s total bandwidth (DDR2-1066) + 16.0GB/s
(HT3)]
Packaging: Socket AM3 938-pin organic micro pin grid array (micro-PGA)
Fab location: GLOBALFOUNDRIES Fab 1 Module 1
Process Technology: 45-nanometer DSL SOI (silicon-on-insulator) technology
Approximate Die Size: 258 mm2
Approximate Transistor count: ~ 758 million
Max Temp: 72o Celsius
Core Voltage: 0.825-1.25V
Max TDP: 65 Watts
*Notes:
Black Edition processors support software-selectable increases to memory
controller, HyperTransport, DDR3 and CPU core frequency
MC configurable for dual 64-bit channels for simultaneous read/writes
Here's our test system.
Windows Vista 64-bit SP1 was our OS with Catalyst version 9.5 for testing.
V-sync was disabled.

We'll start off with Crysis which primarily uses two cores.
Here we see the Phenom II X2 550 do quite well scoring fps and topping the
Q9300 from Intel. The 7850 which runs at 2.8GHz lags 12 fps behind. The
Athlon II also lags a bit due to the lack of L3 cache at 50.7fps despite
being only 100MHz slower.

Unreal Tournament 3 supports multiple cores so the Phenom II
X2 can't top the Phenom II X3 which almost matches the X4 955. That said the
Phenom II and Athlon II are still much faster than the 7850.

The quad core processors rule here in Cinebench and we don't see much of a
difference between the dual core Phenom II and Athlon II more than likely due to
L3 cache not being as important in rendering.

Valve map creation also doesn't show much of a bonus from
the large L3 cache of the Phenom II and instead cores rule again.

Valve particle bench renders thousands of particles to test
CPU performance and supports many cores and as such again those CPUs come
out on top. We see a slight decline from the Phenom II to the Athlon X2
7850.

Pov-Ray is another rendering benchmark and again we see the
L3 cache doesn't do much.

Overclocking the Athlon II X2 250 we had pretty good success
ending up just short of 4GHz. It wasn't quite stable but 3.8GHz was smooth
sailing.

Our Phenom II X2 550 didn't overclock quite as good being
more stable at 3.8GHz and generally stable at 3.7GHz.
Our power consumption was tested with the Radeon 4850. Idle
was taken 10 minutes idle into the Windows desktop and load using Cinebench
10. We don't see much of a difference at idle between the two processors but
more so at load the extra cache of the Phenom II starts to kick in.
| |
Idle |
Load |
| Athlon 7850 |
125W |
160W |
| Phenom II X2 550 |
136W |
176W |
Conclusion:
AMD continues to improve their standing
in 2009 and the Phenom II X2 550 BE and Athlon II X2 250 are both amazing
processors for around or under $100. The 45nm process continues to mature
for AMD and so far at least with Core i7's very high price to entry compared
to an $80 AM3 motherboard AMD is looking like an easier and easier choice.
Things become a little less clear around September when the P55 chipset is
released and Core i5 as it's been called, but that's hard to see
from here and we know at launch those should only be quad core processors
with the cheapest just under $200, so not much cheaper than a Core i7 920 if
you shop around.
Overall while this may not be labeled a banner
year for everyone it is a proof that don't underestimate this company: the
final word is yet to be written on the champion of PC performance. AMD may
not have the top tier now but they aren't out for the count either and
generally offer the best value in any processors under $200 from quad to
dual core.
Comparing the two processors against each other, for
just $15 more the Black Edition Phenom II X2 seem like the obvious choice,
however, as you can see unless you're playing games there's not much
difference between the two processors. If you do plan to do gaming though
the difference becomes immediate of the benefit of the L3 cache and it seems
obvious which to go with. So that's the jist: if you game go for the Phenom
II X2 or X3 if you don't the Athlon II should be fine for everyone else
looking for the best sub-$100 processor.
Pricing:
We don't see the
processors at retail yet but the Athlon II X2 250 should go for $87 and the
Phenom II X2 500 for $102.
Athlon II X2 250 Score: 93%
Phenom II X2 550 Score: 97%
